stevelockett

I have used Drennan Barbless Carp Feeder hooks for my carping for a number of years, but I think a wider gaped hook would be better. Also, something perhaps a little stronger (yes, really!).

The two I've looked at are the Fox Series 2 Extra Strong and the Korum S3.

Having used Fox Series 2 Match Carp, I know that the size 20 is more like a regular size 14, is it the same in the extra strong? So should I choose size 16 if I want a hook closer to a regular size 12? Is the Series 2 Extra Strong thick enough in the wire to be a contender when judged against the Drennan?

Having used Preston hooks, which I find go blunt very quickly, will the Korum stand up to tons of carp? How do they measure up for size and wire thickness against the Drennans?

Thanks in advance for any assistance,
Steve

__________________
"I really rate these V2Vangling DVD's and think they are head and shoulders above the rest that are on the market"
Quote from review on Andy's Angle forum

Want to learn from Will Raison and Neil Machin?
log on to www.v2vangling.co.uk

Go on, you're worth it

Thinking of visiting the Westcountry?
Check out my other site at:
www.coarsefish-torbay.co.uk
For news and views from the Westcountry

bazh

Steve look at the Gamakatsu range they are all I use now for F1's and Carp.

__________________
Clay Lane

stevelockett

Ta Bazh, the only Gama hook that fits the bill is the Specialist, with size 12 being the smallest. Ordered some Fox 2XS's to see how I go with them.

__________________
"I really rate these V2Vangling DVD's and think they are head and shoulders above the rest that are on the market"
Quote from review on Andy's Angle forum

Want to learn from Will Raison and Neil Machin?
log on to www.v2vangling.co.uk

Go on, you're worth it

Thinking of visiting the Westcountry?
Check out my other site at:
www.coarsefish-torbay.co.uk
For news and views from the Westcountry

zak70

steve,i have changed over to the drennans this season after always using b911's for all my carping,i just wondered are you looking to change just for the reasons you stated or are you having any other problems with these hooks as i am getting on really well with them.

justin case

911's and 175's for me

although I must add I had my first 911 get straightened on Sunday I think I hooked the Orient Express

__________________
Life at the bottom A noobs guide (My Blog, Paul Law)

JJGallagher

turbi 175 the best hook on the market the hook hold is fantastic even with foul hookers give them a try you won't be disapointed.

stevelockett

Zak, I'm only changing because I think they are not quite the right shape. I have had some pull out of fish on the pellet waggler when using a 16, which makes me think I'm using too small a hook as well as the wrong shape.
I've never had one open out on me.

__________________
"I really rate these V2Vangling DVD's and think they are head and shoulders above the rest that are on the market"
Quote from review on Andy's Angle forum

Want to learn from Will Raison and Neil Machin?
log on to www.v2vangling.co.uk

Go on, you're worth it

Thinking of visiting the Westcountry?
Check out my other site at:
www.coarsefish-torbay.co.uk
For news and views from the Westcountry

Oneabung

Steve, believe it or not I personally believe you pull out of less fish on a smaller hook on the wag.

__________________
Simon Young
Admin
www.TalkAngling.co.uk
Online fishing tackle shop

matt6900

i have thought the same about the carp feeder everyone i know rates them but im ALWAYS pulling out of fish on them no matter what rod im using or the method im fishing, i too dont have any confidence in the shape, so would be interested to hear your findings, i use the pr36's for alot of my hair rigging now but there not really for bagging days!

__________________
Matt Smith
Mosella

zak70

cheers for your reply steve,i do agree with oneabung thou i seem to pull out of less fish with a smaller hook on with the pellet wag,used with my shakey micro pellet wag rod and tdr ive had some good results.